Against all odds: A planmaking triumph of perseverance over adversity
July 23, 2021
Heather Pugh
945 Views
Following the issuing of the Inspectors’ Report finding the Central Bedfordshire Local Plan sound, the authority adopted its Plan last night – a significant milestone for several reasons.
Notably, this is the fourth local plan the authority has attempted to get over the line since the removal of any meaningful regional context shaping the direction of new growth for in the area. Despite heroic efforts of officers, the local plan has wrangled with the adjoining Borough of Luton around affordable housing nomination rights (an issue falling outside of the scope of a Local Plan); struggled with recalcitrant neighbours over the Duty to Co-operate; and been impacted by the failure of statutory agencies to progress feasibility, funding and testing of proposed strategic highway improvement schemes (including the Transport Secretary’s ‘about-face’ on the Expressway proposal which runs through the district).
Furthermore, as a district with a dispersed settlement pattern and no main town or city around which to focus growth, Central Bedfordshire made a bold decision to move away from a continuation of ‘edge-settlement’ incremental expansion, to propose a growth strategy which included a new settlement within the Marston Vale, an area of former brickworking equidistant between Bedford and Milton Keynes.
The recent shortcomings of ‘new settlement development plans’ are many and well documented. In getting the Central Beds Plan over the line, the authority has succeeded where so many of its compatriots are failing.
But it has been a long road to get here; and this is perhaps the key message upon which to reflect.
The Marston Vale has long been recognised as a potential location for strategic development and environmental regeneration. However, despite high level policy recognition for strategic growth in this location for 16 years – including the Milton Keynes South Midlands Sub Regional Strategy published in March 2005, and the Government’s ill-fated EcoTown initiative in 2009 – it has only been since 2017 that a new strategic growth allocation has found its way into a locally-prepared development plan.
The area has been promoted through the development plan system by landowner O&H since the year 2000, supported by DLA as master planners and designers. Against the tide of decreasing support for larger-than-local planning strategies, many landowners would have simply given up after the third local plan failed at Examination.
Instead, O&H took the decision to proceed with an OPA for the proposed new settlement despite the lack of a current plan or allocation. Extensive consultation on the draft scheme with local people took place to inform its design, and an application was lodged in 2018 with the planning authority for a new settlement which includes 5,000 homes and 30 ha of employment land in parallel with – and as it turned out, to inform – the local plan progression.
The decision was not universally supported, with some quarters perceiving that this somehow cut across the proper planning system. However, had it not been for the detailed design and technical analysis submitted with the application, many of the objections raised by local people at Examination – and indeed, questions posed by the two Inspectors – would not have been able to be explained and the ‘evidence’ provided to resolve their queries.
Examining a ‘real scheme’ as opposed to a theoretical proposal proved to have considerable benefit in this regard, giving confidence and certainty that what was being allocated would be delivered. We were able to draw on a wealth of tested technical evidence at the Examination, supporting the Council through what was a hugely detailed and scrutinised evidence base.
The successful local plan outcome is due in no small part to the priority given by CBC to resourcing officer time and expertise over at least four years of intensive consultation, evidence gathering and analysis, Examination appearances and proactive engagement with local stakeholders – including those both for and against the developments proposed. Any policy officers considering how to embark upon a local plan review would do well to look at the CBC local plan website, particularly the way in which the early-stage spatial options were explored.
Sighs of relief all round, then. But the hardworking policy officers will only get a few months reprieve: para 51 of the Exec Committee report states: “Whilst the plan period set out in the document is 20 years, the Local Plan includes a policy commitment to undertake a partial review of the plan commencing within six months of its adoption date. This will assist the Council in responding to a number of emerging strategies, including the Oxford/Cambridge Arc Spatial Framework and potential changes to the planning system”.
So, enjoy the summer recess all; we’ll be back to the drawing board come the Autumn!

Heather Pugh
Partner
RELATED NEWS
Great Leighs, Chelmsford City Council, Essex – Strategic Growth Site
March 15, 2023
Masterplan Framework document to deliver around 950 new homes, 250 specialist elderly dwellings, together with a neighbourhood centre, site for a primary school and a Travelling Show-persons site, all set within a mature landscape setting adjacent to and integrated with the existing village.
Proposed Reforms to the NPPF, Summary Response
March 7, 2023
In December 2022, the UK Government released a consultation document proposing changes to the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF). You can read our summary response to this consultation here.
Project Skyway
February 21, 2023
David Lock on why we need to talk about a proposed long-distance network of drone based delivery ‘superhighways.’
Promotion at David Lock Associates
February 9, 2023
DLA is pleased to announce the promotion of Emily Benstead to the role of Planner. This recognition is a result of Emily achieving Chartered Member status with the RTPI and her noteworthy work as an Assistant Planner.
Houlton School wins RTPI Award for Planning Excellence
December 5, 2022
Houlton School wins the RTPI Award for Planning Excellence for ‘Excellence in Planning for Heritage and Culture’
DLA Working With STFC
October 27, 2022
David Lock Associates is delighted to be working with the Science and Technology Facilities Council (part of UK Research and Innovation) on a series of exciting development plans, which are helping to facilitate world-leading research.
Build Your Career at DLA
October 24, 2022
We are looking for enthusiastic, bright and committed graduate planners to join our leading spatial planning practice next summer.
New Recruits and Promotions at DLA
October 18, 2022
David Lock Associates is delighted to announce several new appointments following a recent recruitment drive, and promotions from earlier this year.
Speedy Approval for Prospero Ansty Business Park
October 3, 2022
David Lock Associates recently secured full planning permission for three flexible B2/B8 units at Prospero Ansty Business Park in Rugby Borough, which would deliver a combined floorspace of over 50,000 sq.m.