Building Better, Building Beautiful Commission – Call for Evidence?
May 20, 2019
Simon Pugh
3465 Views
I read the recent announcements that the Commission for BBBB have decided to start their activities with a ‘call for evidence’ with a sinking heart. Am I alone in thinking this is absolutely the wrong place to start?
Following passage through The Houses of Parliament, The Commission for Architecture and the Built Environment (CABE) was dissolved by the Conservative Government on 21 January 2012 via statutory instrument, with Tourism and Heritage Minister at the time, John Penrose saying “CABE did a lot of good work and much of it will continue in different places. The organisation may be coming to an end under the order, but its work and the principles that it embodied will continue. I hope and expect that the public sector’s commitment to good design in our built environment will continue, too.”
The aim of CABE was to improve quality, or ‘beauty’ (in its latest iteration). Good design principles haven’t changed. So why on earth would the ‘Building Better, Building Beautiful’ Commission’ now propose to spend more hundreds of thousands of pounds, untold hours from professionals and consultancies, and take a couple of years to get to basically the same place?
Located (hidden away) in the National Archives is the CABE website[1]; transferred there on 18 January 2011, just 17 days after its last publication on 1st January 2011. It holds an immense library of pretty much everything CABE did in its 12 years of existence. This includes 309 publications, across 47 categories/subjects, including public space; planning; housing; neighbourhoods; the value of design; parks and green spaces; regeneration; streets; school design; and of course, design review. The design review process as advocated by CABE remains an excellent way of raising design standards: requiring rigorous design evolution and clear articulation by project professionals to be undertaken prior to engaging in a formal peer review process to ensure the best possible design for a new, expanded or regenerated place.
At DLA, our multiple experiences with design review panels were overall very positive, our main frustration being that some of the panel members selected for various projects – particularly the large scale ‘new places’ that DLA is well known for and has so much experience – simply didn’t have the required credible experience to be able to review such projects. In the main, the panels were chaired by excellent professionals such as Ben van Bruggen, who ensured that a proportionate, balanced and constructive view was given.
CABE’s 309 publications – prepared in a measured and comprehensible way – took 12 years to produce and did raise the bar for design quality. Can we afford the time and cost of going through this process again when design quality is given such little relative weight at present, but development at speed to deliver new homes and jobs is an absolute priority?
Have good design principles changed that much that we need to re-invent the wheel yet again? No, of course they haven’t. Please, please please, let’s use the knowledge and evidence gained, and numerous comprehensive publications already in the system to get design back on the main agenda as quickly as possible. Review, rebrand, refresh, of course; put in place a new ‘champion’; absolutely – someone to be the ‘face’ and drive behind it – but let’s not take another 12 years to build the same body of guidance and evidence.
Having looked through the matters and questions posed in the recent call for evidence, are there any elements that could not be answered exceptionally well by re-activating the information and documents safely stored (hidden away) in the National Archive?
Simon Pugh is a Partner at David Lock Associates Ltd. The views expressed are his own.
[1] https://webarchive.nationalarchives.gov.uk/20110118095905/http://www.cabe.org.uk/home
RELATED NEWS
Digital Dagenham
February 24, 2021
During the global pandemic the importance of data centres has been realised, they are key pieces of national infrastructure. Keeping our laptops, zoom calls and mobile phones working during the day, before we watch streaming services in the evening.
Circle Health Rehabilitation Hospital shortlisted for 2021 RTPI Planning Award
February 19, 2021
David Lock Associates and our architect colleagues at Bryden Wood have been named as finalists in the category for Planning for Health and Wellbeing at the Royal Town Planning Institute (RTPI) Awards for Planning Excellence 2021.
Logistics Permission Secured by DLA
February 15, 2021
DLA have successfully secured detailed planning permission, on behalf of our client Baytree Logistics Properties.
Promotions at David Lock Associates
February 9, 2021
David Lock Associates is delighted to announce the promotions of Victoria Owen and Matthew Hewitt to Planner positions with the compan
Doncaster Railway Station
February 8, 2021
We are delighted to see the regeneration story at Doncaster continuing at pace with the completion of the new Railway Station Gateway.
Virtual Work Experience
January 12, 2021
Friday marked the end of our second week of Virtual Work Experience at David Lock Associates. Building on the success of our previous Virtual Work Experience, we wanted to expand the number of students that could take part this time and also refined the programme to incorporate feedback from our previous attendees.
DLA Feature in RIBA’s London 21 Directory
January 11, 2021
DLA are proud to be included, with our architect colleagues at Bryden Wood, in the London 21 RIBA publication for the recent best in class delivery of the Circle Health rehabilitation hospital.
Standard method and constraints in five plans
December 17, 2020
The Planning for the Future White Paper proposes establishing housing requirements that factor in land constraints. This blog analyses how this could work and what the effect of the proposal would be on local planning authorities across England.
Recruiting Ambitious Planners
December 14, 2020
We are recruiting Associate and Senior Associate level planners to join our busy and innovative company.
DLA is recruiting experienced masterplanners
December 9, 2020
We are looking for senior masterplanners with an outstanding track record to work on some of the UK's most significant growth and regeneration challenges, for prestigious and forward-thinking clients. Find out more here.