Is a new era dawning for urban design and planning? Don’t bank on it just yet
June 11, 2020
Joanne Cave
1563 Views
I have read with great interest the thoughts of those urban designers, planners and other built environment professionals who have been writing about the types of places we would like to help create, post-pandemic. It would be hard to disagree with the wisdom expressed, formed as it is over years of observing and understanding how great places are crafted by many players to successfully set the scene for vibrant urban life in all its guises.
Of course, we need attractive streets with more space for pedestrians and cyclists. Certainly, we need much better urban air quality, and the type of world class public transport system that deregulation cannot provide us with. We need better space standards to prevent overcrowding and we want flexible accommodation so we can easily work from home. We need more housing choice to better fit with different household requirements. We need gardens, safe parks and space for nature, as well as local high streets selling fresh produce at the centre of walkable neighbourhoods. And we need these things to be detailed so that they are beautiful, promote our sense of wellbeing and regional diversity, and are available to everyone.
None of this is new to us. We have been promoting these sensible principles for decades and sometimes, when land values support it, and when developers are able to take a long-term approach to returns, great places are made. But too often we end up with mediocrity. We are as familiar with the images of very poor peripheral housing estates as we are with photos of best practice places. The responsibility for poor places is not attributable to any single sector of our industry, but a culmination of several factors including a focus away from planning for people, a point so eloquently highlighted in the TCPA’s Raynsford Review of 2018.
https://www.tcpa.org.uk/Handlers/Download.ashx?IDMF=30864427-d8dc-4b0b-88ed-c6e0f08c0edd
So, what makes us believe now, when the greatest recession for centuries is looming, that we are about to enter the sunlit uplands of widespread, exemplary development? In spite of its commitment to the recommendations of Living with Beauty (beauty by whose standards?) Government will be keener than ever to ensure there are no impediments to the construction industry’s remobilisation, because this is a tried and tested way to reboot the economy and up GDP. This seems inevitable when investment in land and property continues to be highly lucrative for those who can afford to participate on some level. I read recently that 85% of all stock of British bank lending, which totals £1.7tn, is on real estate (as opposed to say business lending).
In short, whilst I agree that we need a transformational change in the way towns and cities are built, we are unlikely to see radical change in many of the proposals coming forward. But this doesn’t mean we shouldn’t be learning from this unique situation. We have witnessed a shift in the nation’s psyche, and we need to carry this forward as evidence of a deep-rooted desire for a different type of society, occupying a different sort of place. Armed with this, urban designers and planners are well placed to lend weight to a coordinated campaign for changes to public policy so that success is measured not by the financial uplift in the value of property, but by a different outcome of the whole planning, design and development process, one in which everyone has a decent place to call home in a part of a town or city that is safe, clean, beautiful and more equitable.
I hope that practitioners and academics continue to write their optimistic articles and papers, because they demonstrate a strong consensus about best practice in urban design and planning. But can we also recognise that our knowledge and skills are of critical importance to the wider national debate about how we rebuild Britain in a post-pandemic time. It’s time for built environment professionals to project our thoughts beyond our immediate and converted audience, and to call on our representative bodies and institutions to join together in leading a campaign to reassert the core values and principles that motivated us to choose this career path. This campaign needs to be dynamic, noisy and unapologetic, and we need to get behind it with unparalleled enthusiasm.

Joanne Cave
Partner
RELATED NEWS
Great Leighs, Chelmsford City Council, Essex – Strategic Growth Site
March 15, 2023
Masterplan Framework document to deliver around 950 new homes, 250 specialist elderly dwellings, together with a neighbourhood centre, site for a primary school and a Travelling Show-persons site, all set within a mature landscape setting adjacent to and integrated with the existing village.
Proposed Reforms to the NPPF, Summary Response
March 7, 2023
In December 2022, the UK Government released a consultation document proposing changes to the National Planning Policy Framework (NPPF). You can read our summary response to this consultation here.
Project Skyway
February 21, 2023
David Lock on why we need to talk about a proposed long-distance network of drone based delivery ‘superhighways.’
Promotion at David Lock Associates
February 9, 2023
DLA is pleased to announce the promotion of Emily Benstead to the role of Planner. This recognition is a result of Emily achieving Chartered Member status with the RTPI and her noteworthy work as an Assistant Planner.
Houlton School wins RTPI Award for Planning Excellence
December 5, 2022
Houlton School wins the RTPI Award for Planning Excellence for ‘Excellence in Planning for Heritage and Culture’
DLA Working With STFC
October 27, 2022
David Lock Associates is delighted to be working with the Science and Technology Facilities Council (part of UK Research and Innovation) on a series of exciting development plans, which are helping to facilitate world-leading research.
Build Your Career at DLA
October 24, 2022
We are looking for enthusiastic, bright and committed graduate planners to join our leading spatial planning practice next summer.
New Recruits and Promotions at DLA
October 18, 2022
David Lock Associates is delighted to announce several new appointments following a recent recruitment drive, and promotions from earlier this year.
Speedy Approval for Prospero Ansty Business Park
October 3, 2022
David Lock Associates recently secured full planning permission for three flexible B2/B8 units at Prospero Ansty Business Park in Rugby Borough, which would deliver a combined floorspace of over 50,000 sq.m.