The Planning system has been relaxed – The implications PART 2
July 6, 2020
Debbie Lloyd
2500 Views
Part one of this blog considered the temporary measures which have been introduced regarding relaxation of the rules on change of use in the high street and the extensions to permissions that have been granted. However, as the economy adapts to different ways of working, shopping, and socialising, there are profound implications for the way in which we will use buildings in the future and the demand for buildings in different sectors.
The second half of this blog looks at how demand for property in each of the major sectors may be impacted and how changes of uses might assist in reducing the spectre of increases in vacant property.
Offices
• Changes in the demand for traditional office space in towns and city centres and a potential move to the suburbs;
• Fear of a ‘vicious cycle’ of tenants unable to pay rent/rates, landlords not paying tax or defaulting on mortgages, and the system starting to crumble.
Retail
• Acceleration of the trend towards online shopping and the exacerbation of the structural changes already evident on the High Street;
• Consumers showing a preference towards smaller towns centres which are more accessible by bike or on foot reducing reliance on public transport;
• Expected closure of many retail outlets such as Debenhams.
Housing
• A call for a review of densities in town and city centres;
• More private outdoor space for apartment blocks;
• Demand for well-planned adaptable live/work space;
• Housing closer to service centres.
Leisure
• Expected increase in staycations but less business travel changing locational demand for hotels;
• More emphasis on self-catering;
• Reduction in demand for indoor leisure activity and
• More outdoor weatherproofed areas for pubs, cafes and restaurants.
Warehousing and manufacturing
• Increased need for resilience in supply chains with demand for more space to hold stock, especially in the food and medical sectors;
• Reduced dependence on the supply of goods from one source e.g. China and a move to more local manufacturing and
• Increased demand for high tech space in the life sciences sector.
Changes in demand by Sector
Sector | Winners | Losers | Potential for change of use |
City/town centre Offices | √ | Live/work space
Residential* |
|
City centre Retail/ Shopping centres | √ | Current temporary changes to become permanent e.g. restaurants to take away
Residential Live/Work |
|
Local High Street | √ | Although some retail may be lost (most likely to residential) smaller centres are predicted to fare better than their city centre counterparts | |
Leisure | √ | Warehousing for out of town sites
Residential in urban centres |
|
Warehousing | √ | ||
High-tech manufacturing | √ |
*Already allowed through the GDPO, subject to limitations and conditions, including the need to apply for Prior Approval.
Whilst the temporary measures are welcomed, clearly there is need for a more radical rethink of the planning system. Measures which accelerate the change of use of existing buildings could also unlock the pipeline of permissions which are technically unimplementable, but now commercially unviable.
There have been a number of announcements around the Government’s Post-COVID Recovery Plan hinting at an overhaul of the planning system, but last week’s statement from 10 Downing Street provides more detail regarding the Government’s plans. In a letter to MPs the Secretary of State, Robert Jenrick, added flesh to the bones.
Among the changes proposed are:
• The creation of a new broad category of ‘commercial, business and service’ uses which will allow commercial, retail and leisure uses greater freedom to adapt to changing circumstances.
• A broadening of Permitted Development including leave for homeowners and commercial building owners to extend their properties upwards to create more space via without a planning application.
• Removal of the need for a “normal planning application to demolish and rebuild vacant and redundant residential and commercial buildings if they are rebuilt as homes”.
Whilst these changes are welcome to ensure business can respond quickly to the changing economic environment, the speed with which the measures are being introduced means that the opportunity to review alternatives to the relaxation of Permitted Development rights may be lost. Much has been written about the consequences of the offices to residential relaxation which was brought in in 2013. It is widely recognised that schemes delivered through PD exhibit a significantly worse residential quality than that in schemes which require planning permission. Any reform should seek to ameliorate a process which allows poor quality development through the back door not encourage the opening of Pandora’s Box.

Debbie Lloyd
Development Consultant
RELATED NEWS
Refurbishment of Mortimer Square, The Hub Milton Keynes
September 13, 2023
The square was in need of refurbishment to create a more usable and attractive public space, that also benefitted the business that operate out of the area.
Recruiting Planners
August 15, 2023
We are currently recruiting MRTPI chartered planners/senior planners to join our dynamic planning and masterplanning practice.
Mexborough Futures Masterplan
August 2, 2023
The City of Doncaster Council have produced the Mexborough Futures Masterplan, a comprehensive masterplan to guide future investments and address key challenges in Mexborough Town Centre.
Policy Considerations for Site Allocations
July 31, 2023
One of the main purposes of local plans is to allocate sites to deliver strategic priorities. But what is in national policy and guidance to help authorities and practitioners with this process – from identifying sites to assessing sites to selecting sites for allocation.
End of Term Report
July 21, 2023
As we reach the end of the academic summer term, we’ve taken a look back at some of our activities in helping encourage and inspire the next generation of planners and urban designers.
DLA Working Towards Planet Mark Certification
July 18, 2023
We are proud to announce that we are working with Planet Mark to measure and reduce our carbon footprint, ensuring that we build further on sustainability in our business practices.
Resolution to Grant Bluehayes Community
July 13, 2023
The new Bluehayes community will consist of 870 additional homes and is a key part of the planned growth for Cranbrook which will take it to 8,000 new homes.
Detailed Planning Permission Secured for Baytree Leeds
June 28, 2023
David Lock Associates (DLA), on behalf of our client Baytree Logistics Development Ltd, has secured detailed planning permission for the redevelopment of the former Maritime container depot in Leeds.
David Lock Awarded with Ebenezer Howard Medal
June 20, 2023
At the TCPA Parliamentary Reception yesterday evening, our founder David Lock, was presented with the Ebenezer Howard Medal which recognises the outstanding contribution of recipients to delivering the Garden City Principles.
Active Design Guidance Update Launches
May 24, 2023
The updated Active Design Guidance was released recently, drafted by DLA on behalf of our clients Sport England.